What happened to moderation?

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com
Why so extreme?

My late mother used to say, “All things in moderation”. She didn’t ban me from eating sweets, just said eat a few sweets once in a while. She didn’t ban me from playing video games, just said play for a few hours. You get the picture. Moderation makes things palletable, solves problems, and settles arguments.

It is a grown-up mindset which is sadly vanishing from the modern world. Everyone wants everything 100% their way. Everything has to be over-done, extreme, shouted, stamped out, banned outright, cracked down on. Moderation isn’t an option. Applying some restraint, some caution, some compromise, can provide a smooth way out of a lot of situations. But compromise, too, seems no longer seems to be in vocabulary of modern society.

Politics used to be less extreme, more debate-driven, more able to accomodate compromise. Now, everyone wants to be able to say, “I did it my way”.

Leave means leave

A soft(er) Brexit would’ve been far more bearable for the vast majority of people; a little moderation and compromise would have really taken the sting out, enabled a continuation of free trade and not erected so many barriers. For example if we’d stayed in the single market and customs union, the threat to export-led business would have been largely neutralised. But no, an extreme ideology triumphed over logic and, as a result, moderation was tossed aside; we’re out, and out hard, because it had to be 100% extreme and full-on and without compromise. “Leave Means Leave”, remember? That slogan was actively trying to eliminate the very idea of applying moderation. And we see the undeniable damage as a result. History will show this whole thing as one of the clearest examples of why calm moderation and compromise should be applied to major decisions, regardless of the loud screams for extreme action.

Strict Covid passports

In the UK, Covid Passports are being proposed as a means to access social venues. No moderation, no compromise, no restraint: Just ban people from entering unless they hold a certification. But what if a person can’t be vaccinated for practical or medical reasons? Or they haven’t been summoned to get injected yet? What if they’ve had the virus and got immunity? Can’t we just use a bit of human brain power here, and give people a little more credit? Allow social venues to put up signs poltely requesting that only vaccinated people may enter. This will perhaps not be 100% effective but it will remove a lot of bad feeling and contraversy and settle the argument without having to be extreme about it. The idea of identifying yourself with a Covid Passport has sinister undertones but these would be tolerable if the proposition was strictly time-limited, for example six months only. But it’s permanent. No moderation means no logic and no caution. Unrest will follow.

Extreme flag waving

The UK government’s current obsession with waving flags has unsettling political tones but again, there is no moderation here. It’s gone to the next level. Waving a flag once in a while is alright, because it’s a reminder of values, it’s a reminder of who we are. But to wave that same flag every single day, at every possible opportunity, constantly, one becomes desensitised and the repetition renders the symbolism almost meaningless. Where is the moderation?

Police, Crime and Sentancing Bill

This is the proposed UK law that makes you liable for a 10 year prison sentence if you make a loud noise outside parliament, or protest against something vocally in public even as a sole individual. Crack down. Ban it. Stop it. Stamp it out. Silence it. Apart from the obscenity of such a law, it’s counter productive, as trying to silence a speaker only prolongs the argument. There was no need for any of this; laws already exist to punish vandalism and breaches of the peace. Protest isn’t a crime. Where is the moderation?

The nutcracker and the sledge hammer

Moderation, compromise, balance – these are things which are very much liberal traits. Most liberal people don’t insist they have everything their way. We are open to compromise, always. Total bans and stoppages are definitely more right-wing characteristics. Perhaps then we should never have expected a softer, more sensible, business-friendly Brexit from this right wing goverment, or a more carefully balanced management of the pandemic, or anything less than an absurd push for nationalism in times of crisis. After all, why use a nutcracker when you have an 80-seat majority sledge hammer?

The people of the UK have chosen the sledge hammer. Now we feel it coming down on their heads. There is no more compromise, no more balance, no more moderation. Everything is extreme, everything is 100% one way, everything is force fed. There is no room for debate. In fact debate itself, is being stopped.

All good things

Above are just a few examples, all of them UK-centric, but there are plenty more from across the world. Human beings are by nature, solution-seeking, progressive creatures. We don’t like being extreme. We have just lost our way, and forgotten how to work things out sensibly. I believe this is about guidance, we have no proper guidance to keep us on track. Politics isn’t a core school subject in UK schools like Maths or English and many world leaders are driven not by those human solution-seeking instincts but instead by greed, populism and power. Our supposed guiding lights, our leaders, aren’t currently setting the examples we need.

But there is cause for optimism. Things are changing. In the US, Trump is gone and Biden is redressing the balance, focussing on solutions without being harsh or extreme.

Another thing my mother used to say is, “All good things come to he who waits”. Sooner or later, for uncompromising, harsh people, the regret comes, and the glaring need for compromise becomes undeniable in hindsight. Only then might people put away their sledge hammers.

5 thoughts on “What happened to moderation?

  1. I can see where the no moderation thing applies to England and perhaps Wales. But the reality is that there are four very different polities in this dead but doesn’t know it so called union. In Scotland, we have a very different approach. Not perfect, by any means, and with our own demons to face, but definitely very different.

    We’re moving along different paths but we’ll always be next door neighbours.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Very good point well made. I am guilty of thinking Johnson’s insane ramblings are in the name of the whole UK at times when in fact it’s just England and/or Wales.

      Like

  2. Well said, Owen. And your mother was a very wise woman … all things in moderation is a philosophy I’ve always lived by, but these days we are pushed further to the left by the angry mobs on the right who would shove their radical beliefs down our throats. Sigh. I’m not sure that I still believe that “all good things come to he who waits” … I used to, but I’ve been waiting and more bad things seem to be coming than good. At 70 years of age, I don’t think I can wait much longer.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know what you mean. Patience is everything though. The gap between elections can be agonising, but they always come around. I think if Trump returns to power, or if Johnson wins re-election, I will pretty much give up hope in this generation and just hope the kids get it right when they are old enough. I am 47.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I would prefer a gap between elections, for it seems like before the dust has settled from the last, the next is being promoted … endlessly! If Trump … or his offspring … take power in 2024, then all hope is lost for this nation. Much the same if BoJo wins re-election. Neither care one whit about the people they supposedly represent and both are self-serving jackals! Sigh.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s